The cost of a concert ticket is surging, and Massachusetts is acting.
Beacon Hill lawmakers responded with the filing of H.5679, the Great Divide Act, which among other things would impose a cap of 10% on the markup of all ticket resale prices.
As someone who enjoys a good concert, I’m sympathetic. Those in our state hoping to see Olivia Rodrigo or Sawyer Hill or the Boston Symphony Orchestra in the coming months shouldn’t feel like they have to mortgage their house to watch a show. But the Great Divide Act misses the mark in one crucial way.
There are some solid anti-fraud protections in H.5679, like its ban on speculative ticket sales (selling tickets someone doesn’t actually own) and its restrictions on deceptive live events websites. These measures are worth debating and even passing.
But as someone who served not only as a state representative for the 1st Barnstable District but also spent decades in law enforcement, including 21 years with the Massachusetts State Police, I understand that too often the bad guys try to co-opt even the best of intentions.
And here the bad guy is the company more responsible than anyone else for inflation in the ticket market: Ticketmaster.
There’s a reason Ticketmaster’s parent company Live Nation has spoken favorably about H.5679 in the press and previously endorsed ticket price caps like the one in the Great Divide Act. The legislation doesn’t address the root of the affordability problem, and that is music to the company’s ears.
None of which is to say that the bill is ill-intended. By slapping a cap on all ticket resale prices, the Great Divide Act is trying to stop scalpers from taking advantage of consumers. But that’s not the biggest problem.
Too often, a secondary seller, using automated bulk-buying bots, will gobble up hundreds to thousands of tickets the second they go on sale and then massively mark up the price. And this bill does nothing to crack down on bots. It ignores this problem despite a Federal Trade Commission (FTC) investigation uncovering email evidence that a Ticketmaster executive admitted they “turn a blind eye as a matter of policy” to buyers who exceed limitations on bulk ticket sales.
Ticketmaster likely looks the other way at bots because they increase the odds that the company will secure double the amount of fees on each ticket transaction—once from the first sale and then again if the scalpers resell their tickets on the Ticketmaster resale platform.
In the long run, the real beneficiary of the price cap will be Live Nation. The company sells tickets, yes, but it actually rakes in 85% of its money from alternate income streams like venue partnerships and promotions.
Ticketmaster’s competitors, by contrast, make almost all of their money from ticket sales. So while Ticketmaster will be able to recoup any revenue lost to the price cap through its other profit centers, its competitors won’t be so lucky. Those companies will then lose market share and maybe even close their doors, ceding more control over the live events industry to Ticketmaster and allowing it to jack up prices even higher.
Perhaps most concerning of all, the Great Divide Act provides exemptions to the price cap if artists or venues waive it. This is convenient for Ticketmaster, since the company owns or manages so many venues and artists.
Buyers and sellers who want to avoid Ticketmaster and the Great Divide Act’s price cap completely will almost certainly turn to the black market where fraud is rampant—in tailgate parking lots, on Facebook, and on questionable sites. As a former law enforcement official, I find this prospect concerning.
Ticketmaster is the number one seller of tickets in the United States by a long shot. It’s the same company that a federal jury ruled in April acts like a monopoly that overcharges fans. It’s also a big business with employees who, as the Justice Department revealed, ran internal Slack channels where customers were called “stupid” and threatened.
We can’t afford to let Beacon Hill’s well-intentioned price cap accidentally push up fraud rates and grant Ticketmaster even more market power. Let’s be smart, fight back, and make sure everyone can enjoy a concert. Let’s take this Ticketmaster-endorsed price cap out of the Great Divide Act so that the thing the bill divides is not consumer welfare—it’s Ticketmaster’s unchecked marketplace dominance.